Bo Kelly made his first start of the 2026 season against Northern Arizona after spending much of his final year preparing from the sidelines. Credit: Jackson Taylor / Mustang News

Bo Kelly starts each day by writing five words in his notebook: “Control what I can control.”

Kelly heard a version of those words from his dad growing up. When he got to college, he began writing those five words down alongside his football notes to remind himself that even on days when he got only 10 reps at practice, he could decide how much effort he put into each one.

From being in and out of the starting quarterback position at Cal Poly, the optimism of stepping onto the field on Saturday never goes away. The frustration that he might spend the game on the sideline lingers, too, but during the week, Kelly prepares as though he’ll be called on.

Over five years at Cal Poly, Kelly has moved in and out of the starting quarterback role. Some weeks, he went through practice knowing he’d be on the sidelines on Saturday. In his final season, he spent most of his Saturdays watching someone else take the first snap, even though he knew what it felt like to lead the offense as Cal Poly’s starter. 

“Obviously it’s kind of something you struggle with,” Kelly said. “You always want to be on the field. Going through a hard-fought week and preparing like I’m going to be the starter and not going in, that can take a toll on your mental.”

Transferring has never been easier, and for quarterbacks stuck behind others on the depth chart, it’s often the first option. 

Kelly never took it. 

Through five seasons of inconsistent playing time, he stayed a Mustang.

“When I do get things that I can control, which are my attitude, my effort and how I prepare, I put my all into that,” Kelly said. “If I’m only getting 10 reps a day, I’m making those the best reps I can make to help myself get more in the future.”

In his first season at Cal Poly in 2022, Kelly played in two games to preserve his redshirt status. The following year, he saw more action, playing in seven games while backing up Sam Huard. 

In 2024, Kelly took over as QB1 and finished the season with 1,162 total yards. 

By 2025, the starting job was up in the air. With Kelly, Anthony Grigsby Jr. and Ty Dieffenbach in the quarterback room, it was often unclear who would take the first snap or how long one would stay in. Injuries to the group changed things, though. Kelly got legitimate playing time and was, for all practical purposes, the starter.

This season, however, told a different story. 

Since the beginning of the season, Head Coach Tim Skipper has framed the quarterback room as a “revolving door” and said that the best will always “rise to the top.” Grigsby has carried most of the weight this season, having started nearly every game. 

But even on Saturdays when he knew he would be sidelined, Kelly stayed focused on the game, knowing he could be called in at any time. 

“It’s been a thing that I’ve learned a lot from, just having to prepare week in and week out the same way, not knowing if I’ll be in or not.”

Watching game film, studying the next opponent and reviewing third-down situations, all while giving everything he has at practice with no guarantee he’d take a snap, was what Kelly meant by preparing like the starter.

Being a good teammate is part of the game, Kelly said, but it doesn’t erase the desire to be out on the field.

“At the end of the day, we both are very team-oriented,” Kelly said when talking about him and Grigsby. “All we want to do is win, so I think if you make it about the team, then it doesn’t really have an effect in a negative way.”

It’s easy to overlook the backup quarterback role. Kelly’s final season has barely registered on the stat sheet, but his team has felt his presence from the sideline.

From serving as an extra set of eyes for Grigsby to talking with him about what he sees in the defense and how the offense could adjust, Kelly has found ways to help between snaps, even when he is not directly on the field.

“Bo’s a pro, and I think all backup quarterbacks have to be a pro in the sense that you have to prepare like you’re the starter all the time,” Skipper said. “He’s actually helped us call some plays, and we’ve used that, and it’s worked out there on the field. So I know he’s been locked in mentally.” 

Kelly first took on sideline duties as a freshman, wearing a headset, signaling to the wide receivers and hearing play calls. He’s returned to that role throughout his career, usually on days when he’s out of the lineup. 

While it can be easy for a quarterback room to breed resentment toward one another, Kelly described this season’s quarterback room as one of the closest he’s been part of. Over two seasons together, he and Grigsby have competed for the starting job and trade ideas in film sessions. For Kelly, that competition is part of what makes the relationship work and the team better.

“I want someone very competitive next to me,” Kelly said. “I want somebody to push me to make me better.” 

Skipper said the hardest part of the backup role is the repetition. A quarterback can put in a full week of work and still never take a snap, then has to find the will to do it all over again the next week, knowing the result may not change. 

But against FCS-ranked Montana State on Oct. 31, Kelly got his chance before halftime. 

Against Utah Tech on Oct. 24, Kelly came in for garbage minutes in the fourth quarter with Cal Poly already down big. This time, the Mustangs were trailing 48-0 when Kelly replaced Grigsby in the second quarter, and he stayed in for the rest of the game.

As soon as stepping onto the turf, Kelly connected with Tayvion McCoy for a 28-yard touchdown pass to put the Mustangs on the scoreboard for Cal Poly’s lone touchdown of the night. 

“You put in all this work, and you might not play,” Skipper said. “For [Bo], it happened to where he got in there, took advantage of his opportunities and he was ready to play.” 

Kelly said he didn’t see the deficit as a burden. To him, it was a chance to give the team a spark.

After the game against Montana State, Kelly learned he would start the following Saturday against another ranked opponent, Northern Arizona. His first start of the season would come in his last home game as a Mustang. 

For weeks, he’d put everything he could into each rep at practice, knowing he might spend Saturday on the sideline. That week, he went to practice knowing the first snap would be his.

On Senior Night at Spanos Stadium, Kelly got his first start of his final season at Cal Poly. For months, he had prepared like the starter without being named one.

Looking back, Kelly said he never talked himself out of the possibility.

“I wouldn’t say there was ever really a time it crossed my mind that I didn’t think I was going to play,” Kelly said. “I was always just staying optimistic, staying ready. I never want to check out in any of those moments. For me, it’s always just knowing that my name can get called at any time and just trying my best to stay ready.”

With only the battle of the Golden Horseshoe left on the game schedule, Saturday’s matchup with UC Davis is Kelly’s last game as a Mustang. Whether he takes the first snap or watches from the sideline, the morning will start the same way: with five words in a notebook.

Joslen is a second-year journalism major whose love for sports inspired her to pursue journalism. She got involved with MMG to gain the interactive experience of talking to players and sharing their stories....