Cal Poly Football enters its regular-season finale with a 4-7 record after losing four consecutive games. Credit: Jackson Taylor / Mustang News

A decade has passed since Cal Poly football last had a winning record. I graduated from elementary school that year, and now I’m a senior in college. How can success and failure even be defined when the standards are that low?

Well, the Mustangs started the season off with a 3-1 record in the Big Sky. They even had a chance at making the FCS playoffs, until they lost their last four games in a row by a combined 109 points. 

Their early success was unlikely to last, considering they haven’t won a game by more than one score all season. In fact, they’ve only won 3 games by 9 or more points in the last 2 seasons.

With only the Golden Horseshoe left on November 21 after a bye week, now seems like a good time to consider: has the team even been better than last season?

In 2025, the Mustangs finished 2-6 in conference and 4-8 overall. This season, the Mustangs slightly improved to 3-5 and 4-7. But their point differential actually got worse. They went from -48 in 2025 to -114 in one fewer game this season. 

While record and point differential might not tell the whole story of a team’s performance, they’re a pretty good gauge to measure how happy fans are. 

Another indicator of fan happiness is game attendance, which has fallen off a cliff for Cal Poly in the two most recent home games. In their first 4 home games, the lowest attendance was just over 8,000 fans, and the other three games all hit 5 figures. In the last 2 home games, there were under 6,500 fans. All of those numbers are very similar to the 2025 stats.

But I was there for the Idaho game. I’ve never seen such an electric crowd at any Cal Poly sporting event outside of the Blue-Green games. Granted, it was the beginning of the season when fans are more excited because they can delude themselves into having hope. We all wanted to believe that the team had broken through its worse-than-mediocre ceiling.

READ MORE: Is Cal Poly a football school now?

I should’ve known better. Change is usually slow, so now I’d like to take a step back and look at what’s actually changed from last season to this season.

Cal Poly’s old head coach Paul Wulff was fired after 3 seasons in charge, and new Head Coach Tim Skipper was hired after a 3-6 stint as the interim head coach of UCLA.

Skipper’s UCLA team won 3 straight games after a disastrous 0-4 start to the season (Skipper’s first game as interim head coach was a loss). It wasn’t the first time Skipper had given his team and their fans hope as an interim head coach. He got Fresno State to a bowl game in 2024.

Skipper’s success was more limited at UCLA. The Bruins lost five straight games to close out the season. The falloff at Cal Poly has not been as drastic, but the Mustangs’ record in the first half of the season of 3-3 is certainly better than their 1-4 record in the following games.

Another new factor this season is the completion of the $45 million Madden Center, the facility next to the south endzone in Spanos Stadium. The construction zone was impossible to miss during my first two and a half years at Cal Poly.

READ MORE: There’s construction everywhere I turn on campus. Is it really necessary? 

The Madden Center is essentially a recruiting tool. During the offseason, 39 players were brought in, including 11 transfers. I don’t know how big of a draw the Madden Center is for prospective players. I’d assume that NIL money matters more in the current NCAA landscape, but either way, 39 players is a lot, even for college football. 

Running back Jaden Green and receiver Tayvion McCoy have had arguably the biggest impact of the newcomers. Green has 946 rushing yards, and McCoy has 946 receiving yards, enough to put them third and fourth on the Big Sky leaderboard. On the other side of the ball, Safety RL Miller is eleventh in tackles and tied for second in interceptions in the conference.

Returning players have been important to the team too. Linebacker and captain Kenny Olson is leading the Big Sky with 99 total tackles, while his co-linebacker and captain Mikey D’Amato led the conference in tackles before he got hurt. 

Anthony Grigsby Jr. was the Mustangs’ starting quarterback until their most recent game. He is a returning player, although he wasn’t a starter last year. Ty Dieffenbach had that job but was unable to settle in due to injuries and quarterback rotation. He transferred to UCLA, who is currently ranked 4th in the nation, during the offseason and is now their starting quarterback. 

I don’t know if there was a realistic chance to keep him, but it’s hard not to wonder what could’ve been.

Bo Kelly was also a backup last year (although he did get legitimate playing time), and he replaced Grigsby as the starter in their most recent game. Grigsby started the season with multiple solid performances, but as the season has gone on, his interceptions have shot through the roof, which is why Kelly took his job.

It wasn’t all Grigsby’s fault. Football is a symbiotic sport. The run game opens up the pass game and vice versa. Defense can set the offense up with good field position, and offense can do the same. 

The overall quality of play for the Mustangs has declined over the course of the season, as is reflected in their record. The Mustangs have struggled with injuries in that time. D’Amato was the Mustangs’ most notable casualty, but multiple other starters have missed time this season, including Green. 

It’s also likely that the Mustangs scheme got figured out. Knowing the opponent is more important in football, a strategy-heavy sport, than in basketball, for example. 

With Skipper and new coordinators, Cal Poly’s game plan was a mystery at the start of the season. But their weaknesses in run defense and blocking on offense have been exposed and exploited more and more as the season has progressed. 

Cal Poly has also been involved in a lot of close games this season, so naturally they’ve been involved in multiple upsets. They lost to the University of San Diego–who have a non-scholarship program–and are Utah Tech’s only win of the season. 

They also beat Idaho State, and Idaho on national television. If they lost or won a couple more games, their season would look like a big success or total disaster.

So sure, the Mustangs have a slightly better record than last year, but I don’t think the numbers indicate that they played noticeably better.

For the team to improve next year, they need to get bigger in the trenches. Skipper specifically brought that up after the loss to USD, and it was a problem for the rest of the season. Some weaknesses can be hidden through schemes, but at its core, football is about moving men out of the way.

This season was a disappointment in the sense that the team’s performance didn’t notably improve despite a new head coach, new coordinators and a $45 million facility. What’s the point if it only led to one or two more Big Sky wins?

The upcoming offseason will tell us how serious Athletic Director Carter Henderson and the rest of the decision-makers are about making Cal Poly football a serious team. A team is only as good as its players, and if the Mustangs added some more players like Green and McCoy, they might actually go from bad to mediocre, and if they manage that, maybe they could even be good one day.